User name:



Sign in with Facebook

Not already a member?
Join our community and - Rate & review pubs - Upload pictures - Add events JOIN for free NOW

Chat about:
New pub visits 2022 with ETA on the Pub Forum

Cutlers Arms, Rotherham

S60 1BQ
Phone: 01709382581

Return to pub summary

Reviews (Current Rating Average: 8 of 10) Add Review see review guidelines

Blue Scrumpy left this review about Cutlers Arms

Another Chantry pub, just along the street from the New York Tavern, this pub has a lovely exterior and an equally appealing interior with plenty of tiling. There are a number of different sections. One had a TV which was fairly popular on our Saturday evening visit, as pubs were preparing for the England football match. In fact, as we left, the front door of the pub had been closed to ensure it didn't get too busy.

Ales on were all from Chantry. Diamond Black Stout, Special Reserve & Steelos are regular beers. In addition, they had Cashmere Time, Wentworth Red & Mighty Millers. Similar to the New York Tavern, the 2 real ciders were both from Broadoak - Old Bristolian & Mango Cider.

Plenty of staff were on, but they weren't quite as friendly as others.

On 9th July 2021 - rating: 7
[User has posted 1330 recommendations about 1330 pubs]

Please Note: This review is over a year old.

Will Larter left this review about Cutlers Arms

What a great pub! Fantastic tiled facade, and the interior is on Camra's heritage pubs list. Usually with a full range of Chantry beers, still all priced at £2.50 per pint, even the Special Reserve 6.3%. Service is always friendly and the only time I ever had a beer that wasn't tip-top was when business was slow because of the Covid-19 restrictions. There are bands on most weeks, either on the small stage in the back bar, or on the larger stage in the back yard which has a marquee-type covering. (I saw a Creedence Clearwater Revival tribute band there in 2019 who were really good.) Looking forward to going there again as things open up this spring.

On 6th April 2021 - rating: 8
[User has posted 3081 recommendations about 2897 pubs]

Please Note: This review is over a year old.

Just a quick pint, then I'm off left this review about Cutlers Arms

Quite a grand pub, formerly a Stones house as evidenced by some of the decorative stonework and coloured glazing (and still in much better shape than the long-closed next-door Alma). The 'L'-shaped main bar (with an extra side seating area and small stage) and more comfortable (but empty) lounge bar have retained a number of heritage features too, although much of decor is otherwise quite plain. Rear patio terrace. Now run by Chantry Brewery, I found a full range of nine ales from a total of 13 handpumps, including a decent Diamond Black Stout (£2.50).

On 12th February 2017 - rating: 8
[User has posted 7039 recommendations about 7039 pubs]

Please Note: This review is over a year old.

Gill Smith left this review about Cutlers Arms

Visited this 2016 Good Beer Guide pub on a CAMRA coach tour, and enjoyed beers from the selection of 6 Chantry beers, plus an Abbeydale beer available. There are also real ciders. It is featured in CAMRA's National Inventory of Pub Interiors, and has been well described below.

On 19th April 2016 - rating: 8
[User has posted 1324 recommendations about 1207 pubs]

Please Note: This review is over a year old.

Pub SignMan left this review about Cutlers Arms

This fine Edwardian pub was nearly lost back in 2004 as part of the plans to redevelop the New York waterside area of town, but thankfully campaigners were able to get the property listed, partly as a result of its relatively unspoiled interior. Built in 1907 on the site of two previous pubs, the Cutlers Arms is now one of the leading lights in Rotherham's tentative real ale scene thanks in part to its association with the local Chantry brewery. The pub still retains a good deal of its original features, although rather frustratingly, the right hand side has been opened up a good deal, losing some of the intimacy it might otherwise have enjoyed. You enter through a small porch with stained glass 'Cutlers Arms' panes overhead, into a classic Yorkshire terrazzo floored lobby with the bar over to the left. The servery has a pleasant, curved wooden counter and modern, stained glass Chantry Brewery canopy and serves the lobby and front public bar which is fitted with long banquettes, a smart fireplace and high shelves displaying a collection of bottles. The front windows are perhaps the pub's most striking feature, each with coloured stained glasswork in floral designs with the pub's name, 'Wines and Spirits' and 'Cannon Ales' spelled out across them. The lobby, which extends slightly to the rear where is picks up a corridor leading to the toilets, has some lovely original green glazed tiles, contrasted with modern wallpaper in places. To the right there is a small seating area with modern red padded banquettes around the perimeter, a small fireplace on the end wall and a few old black and white photos on show. To the rear of the bar is perhaps the least appealing area which hosts another long banquette down the back wall under some frosted windows and in the left corner there is a dartboard and a small performance area for live music acts. A remarkably tatty and unappealing garden can be found out the back, where I noticed a BBQ area, a large trailer converted into some sort of stage and a lot of ropey garden furniture.
Chantry beers dominate the bar, with Mighty Millers, Diamond Black, Women of Steel, New York Pale, Stellos Pale, Iron and Steel and 18 Eight all available, plus guests in the shape of Raw Blonde Pale Ale and Lincoln Green Tuck. Two real ciders rounded out a pretty good range, detailed across various boards. My pint of the Women of Steel was pretty good, if not my favourite pint of the day.
I was really pleasantly surprised by this place which in which I'd hoped to satisfy myself with a good ale range but ended up equally enjoying the period surroundings. This is well worth visiting, especially for football fans heading to a match at the nearby New York Stadium, and is a much needed boost for the Rotherham pub scene.

On 3rd February 2015 - rating: 8
[User has posted 2805 recommendations about 2805 pubs]

Please Note: This review is over a year old.

Alan Winfield left this review about Cutlers Arms

The Cutlers Arms is a nice looking old pub that is about halfway down westgate.
Once inside the pub has been opened out into a large single L shaped room,the bar was on the left side,there was some very comforable bench seating to the rear,there was a small stage to the rear left,the front right was slightly seperate from the main room,this area looked very plush with comfy bench seating and chairs.
There was a very good choice of micro beers on the bar,i had a drink of Chantry Iron and Steel which went down very well,the other beers i noted were Chantry New York Pale,Black Diamond Stout and Blue Bee Bees Knees,there were other real ales and some real ciders.
There was some decent background music playing,the pub was quite busy with a good mix of customers on my late Saturday afternoon visit,i got into a conversation and stayed longer that i expected to do.
This pub is well worth a visit.

Pub visited 31/5/2014

On 31st May 2014 - rating: 9
[User has posted 6113 recommendations about 6113 pubs]