Not already a member?
Join our community and
- Rate & review pubs
- Upload pictures
- Add events
JOIN for free NOW
Chat about:
Beer of the Week (w/e 21st June 2026) with ROBCamra
on the Pub Forum
Detail Pages
The Red Lion, Barnard Castle
Cotherstone
Postal town: Barnard Castle
DL12 9QE
Reviews (Current Rating Average: 7 of 10) see review guidelines
Blue Scrumpy left this review about The Red Lion
We were hoping that this would be our favourite pub of the day in County Durham, as we'd booked an overnight stay in the village of Cotherstone. Our hopes were realised.
Opening hours here are limited to 5-9, 6 days a week. We arrived to find the pub busy and there was a constant stream of people coming and going to/from the main bar which is quite compact in size. The room is carpeted with a dartboard above the fireplace and a few trophies standing either side of the fireplace. The bar can be found in the corner, where there is an entrance to another unexplored overflow room. I didn't actually see anybody go through there, with everybody seemingly knowing everybody else and crowding into the bar.
The landlord is a really amiable guy who clearly knows about his beers. Apparently, the pub had longer opening hours before Covid but he has decided to slow down a little, which meant an influx of people coming in just before 9 for last orders and an exodus of people (many of whom headed to the village's other pub) just after 9!
The 2 cask ales are both from Aysgarth - Butter Tubs & Aysgarth Falls. Ciders were Kemp's Special Reserve & Vintage & Snail's Bank Rhubarb Cider, Tutti Frutti Cider, Tumbledown, Alice & Very Perry. I had an interesting conversation with the landlord about the Kemp's. He was surprised that I had previously found the cider in another pub, as he was only aware of the Orb micropub in Darlington stocking it. I had both of the Kemp's ciders, which were just as good as I remembered. The Aysgarth Falls was also in good condition.
Exterior signage is for Cameron's Brewery but the pub does not appear to be under their stewardship (certainly not now, anyway). I thought that the village of Cotherstone was a really lovely place and the Red Lion appears to be the place where most of the villager's congregate and with good reason.
On 3rd June 2026
- rating: 7
[User has posted 3511 recommendations about 3509 pubs]
Please Note: This review is over a year old.
Carl Urmston left this review about The Red Lion
Excellent traditional boozer with a truly unspoilt atmosphere. A corridor gives access to a simply-furnished bar room on the right, with a roaring fire and wall-mounted seating. A further room opens out to the back of this, equally traditionally furnished. No food beyond bar snacks and no hint of gastrification, and no other concessions to modernity. Three beers came from Yorkshire Dales brewery, I tried the best bitter which was excellent. Quiet on a Sunday afternoon with mostly local punters and just the sound of the crackling fire. Teesdale is great walking country and a visit here is thoroughly recommended.
On 16th March 2018
- no rating submitted
[User has posted 26 recommendations about 26 pubs]
Please Note: This review is over a year old.
James Joines left this review about The Red Lion
Traditional pub with open fires, no music or bandits.
Real Ales from Jennings Cumberland, Deucars and a guest from a regional small brewery.
On 3rd May 2008
- no rating submitted
[User has posted 841 recommendations about 835 pubs]